Envy, Socialism, and the Plundering of the Rich

By
Reading Time: 10 minutes

We did not need to observe the great grim experiment of 20th century communism to know that envy is murderous at root. Just as Cain saw Abel’s better sacrifice, and just as Sméagol saw the ring in Déagol’s hand, envy will drive its willing slaves to seek what is not theirs, even at the cost of the beholder’s life. Indeed, even Pilate saw this same desire in those who sent Jesus to his death: “For he knew that it was out of envy that they had delivered him up” (Matt. 27:18).

Of all the vices that plague our age, envy is the most obvious and yet paradoxically, the most well concealed. It is the tap root of so much of the virtue-signalling hypnosis which drives so many institutions and nations into turmoil in pursuit of the unholy grail known as “equality.” This is the Trojan horse in which envy so often hides. Indeed when it comes to the socialist imagination, it may well be the one vice to rule them all. As the proverb says, “envy rots the bones” (Prov. 14:30). It consumes from within.

As so many of the most tragic examples of envy—fictional or historical—tend to occur within families, it is unsurprising that the socialist drive for equality manifestly undermines the concept, not only of the wealth of the family, but of the family as wealth, as the bulwark of societal stability and human flourishing.

Equality Against Aristocracy

Noticing the socialist malaise that was already beginning to take hold in the postwar West, in 1948 Richard Weaver observed:

Equality is a disorganizing concept in so far as human relationships mean order. It is order without a design; it attempts a meaningless and profitless regimentation of what has been ordered from time immemorial by the scheme of things…Not only is this disorganizing heresy busily confounding the most natural social groupings, it is also creating a reservoir of poisonous envy. How much of the frustration of the modern world proceeds from starting with the assumption that all are equal, finding that this cannot be so, and then having to realize that one can no longer fall back on the bond of fraternity!1

1. Richard Weaver, Ideas Have Consequences (University of Chicago Press, 2013), 38–39.

One of our favourite activities as a family is to visit National Trust properties in England. These are large country manors and estates, often with significant history and sublimely cultivated gardens. They are what most people think of when they think “England.” I don’t remember exactly when, but at some point, as we turned the corner of some exquisite architectural feature in one of these houses, it suddenly dawned on me that we probably shouldn’t be there. Why are we and thousands of other strangers allowed to meander around these grand family houses all over the country? What happened to the families who once owned them? The answer is inheritance tax.

Reading the plaques on the wall of the histories of those houses reveals a common pattern: the so-and-so family lived there for 300 years, in this year they had this or that bridge built, in that year they excavated the old monastery ruin, over that decade they renovated the west wing, all while continuing to support the local community by employing or accommodating a large percentage of the village. Alongside the work of keeping the estates managed, the dignified portraits of their ancestors on the walls would remind each lord of the weight of history, ensuring he stewards the immense responsibility of what he inherited for the good of his children’s children, not just inherited land and money, but an inherited legacy. These lords were far from perfect, but their commitment to that legacy meant there was a remarkable continuity to the social fabric which had long made Britain what it was. Then the 20th century happened.

Some form of what became known as “estate duty” had been in existence for centuries, but it increased from 15% on larger estates in 1910, rising steadily between the two world wars, and finally peaking at an astonishing 85% in 1969, with the compliments of the Labour government.2 The government knew, of course, that when the lord of the manor died and passed on his estate, most of those families did not have anywhere near the cash of 85% of the value of their estate to pay these extortionate tax bills, and so would be forced to sell or forfeit swathes of land. In many cases this bankrupted those estates. The families in question had the sacred familial duty to maintain and pass on these estates. In well over a thousand cases, they simply couldn’t do it anymore and either sold at a loss, had the house demolished, or handed it over to the National Trust so that people like me could walk around them and say how noble their way of life must have been before it was taxed into oblivion.

2. Rob Morgan, “A History of Inheritance Tax—Is Reform Likely?” Charles Stanley Direct, August 8, 2024.

The socialist might imagine this state of affairs as akin to Robin Hood, taking from the rich and giving to the poor. But in the long run, the socialist inclinations of the modern state are more like the Sheriff of Nottingham stealing from both the rich and the poor in order to fund an ever-expanding bureaucracy to make the state more and more indispensable and the family less and less valuable.

The Shadows of Rousseau and Marx

As with many of the “revolutionary” stomach ulcers which plague the west today, the ideological spells concocted by Jean-Jacques Rousseau and Karl Marx share a good deal of the blame. Rousseau saw private property itself as the chief catalyst for social injustice, noting that the ambition to increase one’s fortune “inspires in all men a base inclination to harm each other.”3 Things like commercial profit and enterprising land ownership were thus seen as an inevitable oppression of the poor, even if they served to increase the overall wealth of society in a way which directly benefits the poor.

3. Jean-Jacques Rousseau, On the Origins and Foundations of Inequality Among Men (Marc-Michel Rey, 1755), 49–52.

It is no surprise that Rousseau despised patriarchy as the mechanism for inherited familial wealth, seeing the children’s commitment to their fathers’ values and legacy as being, for the most part, a mere cynical strategy to obtain their share of the inheritance.4 It is also no surprise that Rousseau abandoned his own five children to an orphanage, refusing even to see them. He certainly practised what he preached, grim though his doctrine was.

4. Rousseau, Origins and Foundations of Inequality, 58.

A century later, Karl Marx’s ideas about property and society were influenced by Rousseau (as well as by the French Revolution which bore Rousseau’s ideological imprint).5 When Marx and Engels articulated the principles of Communism, they stated that the right of inheritance must first be “curtailed” and that private property should be gradually transformed into “social property” via progressive taxation,6 culminating in “heavy inheritance taxes [and] abolition of inheritance through collateral lines (brothers, nephews, etc.).”7 Although England famously avoided the revolutions of the continent in the 18th and 19th centuries, the gradual protracted process Marx prescribed on taxing the rich is precisely what happened to the English aristocracy. Worse, the same “ethic” of taxing family wealth out of existence now extends to many of England’s ordinary families too.

5. Christopher Bertram, “Jean Jacques Rousseau,” Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, last modified April 21, 2023.

6. Karl Marx and Frederick Engels, Manifesto of the Communist Party, trans. Samuel Moore, ed. Andy Blunden (Marxists Internet Archive, 2010), 58.

7. Marx and Engels, Manifesto, 40, 49.

When God spoke through Samuel of the king whom Israel had requested, one of the principal indicators of his tyranny was that he would extract 10% of their income (1 Sam. 8:17). So conditioned are we to the machinations of socialist ideology, most westerners today would see 10% as benevolent rather than tyrannical. Several years ago, a journalist for the left-wing British newspaper The Guardian even called for a 100% inheritance tax, defending the idea by saying that it only sounds crazy because we’ve been conditioned to think that way:

The idea that we should be able to pass on our life’s accumulated wealth to descendants is deeply embedded. It appeals to the fundamental biological urge to protect your offspring and propagate your genes . . . but why should we be slaves to our biology?8

8. Abi Wilkinson, “Why Not Fund the Welfare State with a 100% Inheritance Tax?” Guardian, July 24, 2017.

Why indeed! If leftists believe you can ignore your biological sex, why not also ignore the natural desire to care for your own children as Rousseau did, or your desire to honour your father and mother, as the pharisees did (Mark 10:9–13)? Why bother seeking “to live long in the land” by such paternal honour (Eph. 6:3)? Why not let all that you worked for become “social property” for Big Brother’s bureaucrats to dispense with as they see fit “for the greater good”? Why not just illegalise personal property altogether, if it really is the fundamental root of all injustice?

While Britain and America still remain a long way away from total collapse into socialism, the germ that Rousseau and Marx sowed remains very much living and active in the western political soil today, having attempted to “upgrade” God’s Word with our own. Just a couple of years ago the British Labour government attempted to introduce a new levy which would have disproportionately taxed family farms (or rather, what’s left of them).9 These farmers’ forebears probably worked the land that was once owned by an aristocrat. Now the government has come to see them as the new aristocrats who must also be taxed into oblivion. After a significant public campaign—which included a mass road blockage by hundreds of farm tractors outside the offices of the civil service at Whitehall, London—the government made a partial U-turn by increasing the threshold on heavily taxed farms (meaning only some of the family farms would be taxed).10 But even this reduced bill was fundamentally immoral, as it was predicated on the idea that individuals do not have a right to pass on their property to their children. What are Christians to make of these issues? How much are we called to care and why?

9. “Agricultural Property Relief—What You Need to Know,” National Farmers’ Union, November 1, 2024, last updated December 23, 2025.

10. “Government U-Turn on Farm Tax: What Today’s Announcement Means for Family Farms,” Farm and Country Finance, December 23, 2025.

Envy, Material Wealth, and the Christian

Many modern evangelicals—particularly in the Reformed tradition—tend to exhibit a pathological sense of guilt over the acquisition of wealth. A pietistic indifference to things like monetary inheritance indirectly resembles the Pharisees’ abandonment of their elderly parents by claiming they have instead given the money to God, which Jesus condemns (Mark 10:9–13). Just as Abel and Joseph were envied by their brothers, so was the prodigal son envied by his older brother who despised the wealth bestowed upon him. Envy is regularly cited in Biblical lists of sins from which Christians must turn away (Mark 7:22; Rom. 1:29; 1 Cor. 13:4; Gal. 5:26; 1 Tim. 6:4; Titus 3:3; 1 Pet. 2:1). That is why Christians should not support the plundering of the rich to the detriment of godly enterprise and dominion. Envy truly does rot the bones.

We would be foolish, however, to ignore the many Biblical warnings against godless accumulation or exploitation of wealth, not least when it leads to the genuine oppression or dishonour of the poor (Jas. 2:1–6; 5:1–6). However easily misapplied by some Christians who might see it as direct guidance for governmental tax policy, we ignore the apostle James’ prophetic thunder at our peril:

Come now, you rich, weep and howl for the miseries that are coming upon you. Your riches have rotted and your garments are moth-eaten. Your gold and silver have corroded, and their corrosion will be evidence against you and will eat your flesh like fire. You have laid up treasure in the last days. Behold, the wages of the labourers who mowed your fields, which you kept back by fraud, are crying out against you, and the cries of the harvesters have reached the ears of the Lord of hosts (James 5:1–6).

The conservative must feel these barbs, recognising that wicked ideas like the Communist Manifesto may well be God’s judgement against those who misused their wealth, giving socialist lies a foot in the door by failing to live generously towards the poor, enabling genuine cause for injustice to become a multi-generational bitterness setting the entire forest aflame. In this sense, the socialists become like the Babylonians used as God’s judgement while perpetrating even greater evils and dismantling the social order in the process.

It should not go unnoticed that it was said of the earliest Christians that they “joyfully accepted the plundering of [their] property” (Heb. 10:34). As Doug Wilson has noted:

When the prehensile and rapacious state seizes my property, like a dragon from the north, I should accept it from the hand of God . . . It’s only stuff . . . And if a property owner’s idolatry is revealed by whatever circumstance, then it stands revealed. But whether or not the victim was an idolator, the thief who revealed that idolatry to the world remains a thief.11

11. Doug Wilson, Mere Christendom (Canon Press, 2023), 32.

It is one thing for an individual Christian to piously accept the plundering of their own property, but another thing entirely to recommend the plundering, or to imagine it as a “Christian” policy rather than a Marxist mutation of social justice. Christians are called to expose the evils of socialist theft rather than shrugging their shoulders and rebuking others for not having “an eternal perspective.” A truly eternal perspective should instead encourage them to see righteousness prevail over evil “on earth as it is in heaven.”

Scripture calls us to honour the Lord with our wealth so that our barns may be filled with plenty (Prov. 3:9–10). Yet it also challenges us not to fill our barns in perpetuity without being “rich toward God” (Luke 12:16–20). Jesus said to the man who asked him to make his brother divide his inheritance with him: “Take care, and be on your guard against all covetousness, for one’s life does not consist in the abundance of his possessions” (Luke 12:15). Jesus is talking there as much to those who covet the wealth of the rich as to those who neglect God in favour of riches. In both cases, the problem is the idolatry of abundant possessions. Ironically, Marxism cannot escape this fundamental problem because it cannot offer any hope of redemption beyond the materiality of possessions, while aiding the destruction of many of the families and legacies that sustain them in order to attain them.

Conclusion

The essence of Marxism is the cultivation of envy and the repudiation of godly hierarchy. It suffocates both giving and gratitude by poisoning us to only see the potential gifts that were not given rather than the abundance which are. While the cry of the socialist may pull the heartstrings to see the oppression of the poor and the effects of economic systems which seem to perpetuate immoral injustice, the Marxist solution is impossible without a far greater propagation of immoral injustice, the completion of which necessarily undermines the foundations of morality itself. Once envy has decreed from on high that the mere possession of a greater portion of wealth or honour is potentially or inherently immoral, there can be no end to the taxes, reparations, or incessant guilt-mongering which may be employed to manifest its will to power.

Where a Christian might see the notion of wealth equalisation as superficially reminiscent of the apparent “undeserved” grace inherent to the Gospel, the Marxist trajectory ultimately breeds unbelief in God’s goodness and a lack of genuine grace, love, and justice toward others by stirring up a system of perpetual resentment, first among the “have-nots”, and then among the “haves” (who soon become the “hads”). If we wish to avoid that which subtly “rots the bones” of our societies and churches today, we must repudiate the insane cultivation of envy. In its place, we must foster the gratitude and generosity which flow from true faith in Christ, the One who was Himself the greatest undeserved gift of all, and the One who bestowed different gifts in differing measures without so much as an apology.

†

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Author

  • Dr Aaron Edwards is a theologian, preacher, writer, and a father of seven. He has lectured at numerous Bible colleges and universities and published various academic books and articles. He is currently freelance and writes regularly on front-line issues of Christian cultural engagement at thatgoodfight.substack.com.

    View all posts
Picture of Aaron Edwards

Aaron Edwards

Dr Aaron Edwards is a theologian, preacher, writer, and a father of seven. He has lectured at numerous Bible colleges and universities and published various academic books and articles. He is currently freelance and writes regularly on front-line issues of Christian cultural engagement at thatgoodfight.substack.com.