From Glory to Greed: How Sports Betting Corrupts the Goodness of Sports

By
Reading Time: 12 minutes

In the concluding episode of the HBO miniseries Band of Brothers, the surviving members of Easy Company are depicted playing an unburdened baseball game not long after Victory in Europe (V-E) Day, May 8, 1945.1 The war-weary and exhausted men of Easy Company are portrayed as smiling, laughing, and at peace for the first time after years prolonged by the horrors of war. Though every account of that specific game is a fictitious insertion by the producers of the mini-series, it intuitively taps into an eternal longing written on the heart of man: that sports are a picture of glory. They evoke something of a memory within the heart of man that longs to see things set right after triumph. The telos of war and conflict is, after all, victory. It is to rightly order what was disordered. The very story of redemption is one about restoring what was lost in Eden in the new heavens and new earth. We see small echoes of that laced throughout Scripture that remind us that we have this orientation toward eternity and the joy of sports reminds us of that. Consider God’s prophetic words about the eschaton through the prophet Zechariah 8:4–5:

1. Band of Brothers, season 1, episode 10, “Points,” directed by Mikael Salomon, written by Erik Jendresen and Erik Bork, aired November 4, 2001, on HBO.

4 Thus says the Lord of hosts: Old men and old women shall again sit in the streets of Jerusalem, each with staff in hand because of great age. 5 And the streets of the city shall be full of boys and girls playing in its streets.

This depiction of play is one where things are at peace and made right. Play exists on a continuum, developing naturally into organized games that introduce competition and eventually into organized sports. This is why it is a fitting ending to Band of Brothers to see soldiers trade their weapons for mitts to play a game of baseball. Whether the writers were self-conscious of this or not, they tapped into a glimpse of glory, the analog of Isaiah 2:4, “They shall beat their swords into plowshares.” When you watch sports, there is a joy that tugs on the heart and yearns for glory. Michael Novak, author of The Joy of Sports says as much when he writes, “Sports have to be among [God’s] glories.”2 Enjoying the game, relishing the play is “[A]s flawlessly as God once imagined human beings might.”3 But for all the goodness of sports and the weighty realities they point towards, a great sickness has intruded upon it that is disrupting, if not threatening to ruin them. The spectacle is viewed with a new set of lenses and the relationship between the athlete and the spectator has morphed. It’s impossible not to notice the intrusion of sports gambling. But is it really ruining sports? Furthermore, is gambling even a sin, or is it a misplaced practice that is simply run amok?

2. Michael Novak, The Joy of Sports: Endzones, Bases, Baskets, Balls, and the Consecration of the American Spirit, rev. ed. (Madison Books, 1993), preface, x.

3. Novak, Joy of Sports, 16–17.

Some Definitions

Before we apply a theological assessment, we need to define what gambling is. Gambling is “an agreement between two parties whereby the transfer of something of value is made dependent on an uncertain event, in such a way that one party will gain and the other lose.”4 The elements associated with gambling include risk, transfer of something valuable (usually money), and uncertainty wrapped up in a “game of chance.” Though we sloppily use the word gamble in our vernacular when referring to something that is improbable or even risky, such as a large investment in a stock that could plummet in value or taking the chance to run outside before a storm hits, these aren’t examples of gambling proper. Something is only gambling if there is an uncertain outcome, and something of value has been risked on that unknown outcome in hopes of winning.

4. Churches’ Council on Gambling (1974), quoted in David H. Field, “Gambling,” in New Dictionary of Christian Ethics and Pastoral Theology, ed. David J. Atkinson and David H. Field (InterVarsity Press, 1995), 402.

For example, car insurance is not gambling because insurance policies exist to mitigate risks, not to win a game. The relationship between the driver and insurance provider isn’t one where you or the insurance company are trying to “win” while the other “loses.” Instead, both you and the company benefit from the transaction: your risk of catastrophic expenses are mitigated, while the insurer profits a small margin from the combined payments of all its customers.5 Similarly, the casting of lots, which is sometimes cited as evidence of gambling in the Bible also isn’t gambling, because while there appears to be an element of uncertainty, the purpose of lots was not to gain something of value but to discern God’s will. For something to be gambling, there needs to be the perceived element of chance, the wagering of money or something of value to gain a prize larger than that originally posited, and the result needs to be that one side loses, and another wins. Gambling involves risk, uncertainty, and transfer of value in a game of chance.

5. Futures markets on commodities (e.g., oil futures or grain futures) operate on a similar principle. Farmers might short the cost of grain on a futures market during planting season in order to protect themselves against a steep fall in the price during the harvest season. By making a bet in a futures market against their own success, they can plant more crops knowing that they will make a profit either way: if there is a supply boom at harvest and prices fall, they won’t lose money because of their investment in the futures market, and if there is a supply shortage at harvest, they’ll sell plenty of wheat at a high price. It’s becoming increasingly popular for young men to treat these markets as an avenue for quick wins on high-risk short-term investments (i.e., gambling via day trading) but at their core, commodity markets are more like insurance.

The Rise of Sports Gambling

When we apply our definition, sports betting clearly counts as a form of gambling. Sports betting exists as a subset of the gambling industry. Once upon a time, sports wagering was tightly regulated and taboo. If you wanted to bet on sports, you had to go to a casino or similar entity to do so. Or, in a darker part of our culture of yester-year, you had to possess your own bookie. The reason both of these venues (bookies and casinos) operated outside of the public eye was the same: gambling was considered shameful. The social stigma against gambling helped preserve the goodness of sports and allowed fans to experience the joy of the game for the sake of the game. Through a Christian lens, we can say that the purer the spectacle of sports is, the clearer the picture of glory is. Not long ago, that picture was remarkably clear in American sports. But a lot has changed in the last decade alone.

In recent years, states have rapidly moved towards legalizing sports gambling. Worse, the advent of mobile apps such as FanDuel, DraftKings and BetMGM have brought gambling out of dark hidden corners into everyday life. Online and mobile sportsbooks now dominate the American sports gambling industry. According to a 2026 report from UCLA’s Anderson School of Management, more than 95 percent of the money wagered on sports in the United States is gambled online,6 while a separate study published by Cambridge University Press found that 71 percent of sports bettors had used their mobile phones to place a wager.7

6. Dee Gill, “As States Permitted Online Sports Gambling, Citizens’ Personal Financial Health Suffered,” UCLA Anderson Review, February 4, 2026.

7. Scott L. Fulford, “Online Sports Gambling and Financial Wellbeing in the United States,” Journal of Financial Literacy and Wellbeing 4 (2026): e2.

Gambling platforms have been carrying out a methodical and intentional agenda of intertwining sports gambling with sports culture itself so that the two are viewed as inseparable. You can’t watch a football game without dozens of ads for sports gambling ads or drive more than a couple miles down the interstate without being accosted by billboards normalizing the practice. Worse, the appearance of truly great athletes such as Tom Brady (football), Wayne Gretzky (hockey), LeBron James (basketball), and Derek Jeter (baseball) in these commercials communicates to the spectator: “This is normal; this is how it’s always been; this is sports culture as it is; this is good; this is what sports are in its essence.”8 But this is a subversive lie aimed at infecting the fan culture of each of these sports. Nearly all greatness of these men’s careers was achieved before sports betting invaded a culture they once helped cultivate. Betting apps are even attempting to make gambling vernacular standard among non-bettors. Whereas sports journalists and TV pundits of past decades would make predictions about games only based on winners and losers, they now often do so according to gambling “lines,” explicitly connecting the entertainment of sports with wagering.

What makes sports betting particularly alluring is how potent it is. For example, a bet between friends or in an office pool would usually simply be for which team wins. Now the betting is often condensed into a parlay. A parlay combines two or more individual wagers into a single bet, typically requiring every selection to win for the bettor to receive a payout. A parlay boosts the amount you can win with a small bet,9 but drastically decreases the chance you will win at all. Research from Rutgers University found that parlays lost approximately 86 percent of the time, with longer parlays losing as often as 95 to 98 percent of the time.10 Rather than representing a reliable strategy for financial gain, these wagers often resemble lottery tickets: small stakes placed on highly improbable outcomes in hopes of a substantial payday. The potent nature of sports betting disrupts the goodness of sports by accelerating their bets to a frenzied experience of “micro-bets.” Yard by yard, pitch by pitch, into a frantic experience likened to a slot machine.11 The rapid-fire stimuli bombarding the bettor turns off any sense of making a rational decision based on the statistics or knowledge of the game as the spectator gives themselves over to an enthralling experience that is marketed as a moral good.

9. FanDuel itself reports that 60 percent of its same-game parlays involve wagers of $5 or less. See “Key Facts About FanDuel and Sports Betting,” FanDuel, accessed November 10, 2026.

10. Lia Nower et al., Sports Wagering in New Jersey: Calendar Year 2020 Report to the Division of Gaming Enforcement (Rutgers University, 2023), 17–18.

11. Danny Funt and Timothy Fong, interview by William Brangham, “How Sports Betting Is Changing Our Brains and Behavior,” Horizons from PBS News, February 6, 2026.

The sobering reality is that most bettors will never even break even. One study put out by the University of California found that 96% of its online gamblers lost money,12 and 52% of Gen Z investors have redirected money intended for investing toward sports betting.13 Whereas investments in the stock market build a family’s assets long-term and contribute to the growth of the whole economy, sports gambling is a system where every time someone wins, someone else loses. Over time, everyone loses because the total amount of bettors have keeps getting smaller as the “house” (the gambling platform) builds in an edge to make sure they win in the long run.

The explosion of legalized sports gambling has been staggering. In 2018, Americans legally wagered approximately $6.6 billion on sports.14 By 2025, that figure had skyrocketed to nearly $167 billion, a more than twenty-fivefold increase in just seven years.15 As Fortune reported in July 2026, the total amount wagered on sports exceeded the combined annual revenues of America’s movie, music, concert, book publishing, and museum industries.16 Nigel Eccles, the co-founder of FanDuel, made a stunning admission when he stated, “They’re selling that you can win, but you can’t.”17

Yet the moral challenges present in sports gambling run deeper than whether the odds can ever turn in your favor or not. The deeper issues are what gambling does to our hearts and how it distorts our view of God.

Theological Analysis

The Goodness of Work Thwarted

Gambling in general and sports gambling in particular offer a shortcut to enjoy the fruit of another’s labor at the expense of another’s. It is a cheap substitute for work that appears to skirt past the toil placed upon work after the fall of mankind in the garden. Ponder how it disguises itself in this way: If you place a $50 bet and win, you could walk away with $5,000. That’s next month’s rent, food, and car payment. Just think if you win two or three more times. It’s seductive and even fun as it tempts one with an improbable outcome. In this way it’s strikingly akin to how sin presents itself in Genesis 3: “You will not surely die (Gen. 3:4)” there will be no consequences and, “You will be like God (Gen. 3:5),” you will receive unattainable rewards. The potential payout presents itself to the gambler to cause them to think, “This will provide for me.” But to look to anything outside of God as our provider is idolatry and attempting to avoid work, which God has ordained and commanded, is sin.

Stewardship of God’s Resources Assailed

The money we possess in this life, like our bodies, is not our own. These are God’s resources, entrusted to us for faithful use. Any financial adviser worth his salt will tell you that if an investment you are considering: 1) caused 96% of people to lose money and 2) led 52% of a generation to dip into their college savings to cover their losses, they would scream “Stay away!” Yet we treat ourselves as though we are the exception, and money as though it was solely our own. The wicked and slothful servant who buried his talent was not so foolish with the money the Lord entrusted him with (Matt. 25:26). Rather than waste what God has given, we ought to use to use the resources entrusted to us for God’s Kingdom work.

The Sovereignty of God Assaulted

Proverbs 16:33 reminds us “The lot is cast into the lap, but its every decision is from the Lord.” Every ball, strike, foul and tackle, may now be something you can bet on with high stakes and the appearance of sheer randomness when officiated by the inconsistency of good and bad referees, but there isn’t a single aspect of any game that surprises the sovereign Lord of glory. A heart that participates in the liturgy of sports betting will condition themselves to believe that many, if not all things are the result of sheer random chance. But this is an affront to the character of the God who declares the end from the beginning (Isa. 46:10). It is catechizing the heart to not live by faith, but to live by supposed chance; a false placement which hopes to gain from what it cannot accurately predict. At bottom, it is to act as though you are sovereign over yourself, even savior and provider of yourself, in which you might as well “eat and drink, for tomorrow we die” (1 Cor. 15:32). But this isn’t true. The God who is there delicately holds all things together and our lives must give testimony that we believe this. Therefore, conform yourself to think God’s thoughts after him and not to the pattern of this wicked age.

The Desire for Another’s Wealth Manifested

The thrill-seeking and pursuit of easy wealth through gambling comes at the loss of another. It takes on the desire to own something you do not and gain it, not through the honest fruit of labor, but through supposing one outcome will be more likely than another. It’s a form of covetousness at work, a violation of the tenth commandment (Deut. 5:21). Violations of the tenth commandment are difficult to diagnose because they are matters of the heart. Where adultery begins with lust and works itself outward to physical infidelity, the sin becomes visible, the Old Testament case law prescribed no civil punishment for the tenth commandment. How do we spot covetousness before it manifests itself outward? You don’t go near it! To adopt John Owen’s famous quip, “Be killing sin or it will be killing you” “be killing your desire to covet before you covet!” “But put on the Lord Jesus Christ, and make no provision for the flesh, to gratify its desires” (Rom. 13:14). In other words, don’t go near anything that feeds the insatiable desires of wanting that does not belong to you. Many will think they are the exception when it comes to sports gambling, but wisdom entreats us to not treat our fickle, prone to wander hearts as exceptions, but as the rule.

The Glory of God Disrupted

Sports give us a beautiful, though faint, glimpse of glory. Peace brought through combat; rest through work; art forms and as close to the body functioning without the effects of the fall as we get. The spectator sits in a privileged position to witness that. The athlete participates in the echoes of Eden and the shadows of the eschaton while creation groans (Rom. 8:22) and former athletes long to return to step on the field of play once more. Gambling has disrupted this relationship. Coaches have lost their first love of the sport and fallen for the vain love of money. Spectators have forgotten their love of the sport and have begun to hate their favorite players when they don’t perform to their wagers which cost them sizable bets; athletes feel pressured and loved, not for the skills they possess or the game they play, but for the money their performance wins for bettors that week. The entire enterprise of sports is losing its luster and the faint shimmer of reflecting the glory it gives our God. His storehouses of common grace are abundant, but how long will it be until sports are too corrupted for Christians to participate in with clean honor and a clear conscience?

Conclusion: Walking in the Way of Wisdom

If you’re considering placing a bet or counseling a young man through this new sports landscape, the question you must walk away with and consider is this: “Who will I be?” You are not neutral or unchanged when you participate in sports betting. Scripture doesn’t expressly forbid gambling or sports betting, but you should tread carefully to take that absence of a prohibition as a license to do what you want. You will be hard-pressed to argue that because you chose to participate in sports betting, you’re a better man than if you didn’t. Show me the man who says, “I am more moral, virtuous, courageous, humble, wise, honest, loyal, faithful man of God because I bet on sports regularly.” Make no mistake, participating will change you. It has changed former and current athletes, coaches and spectators. What makes you confident you’ll avoid the consequences others have suffered? Proverbs 6:27 comes to mind: “Can a man carry fire next to his chest and his clothes not be burned?”

†

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Author

  • Josh Holler is an award winning author of Redeeming Warriors: Veteran Suicide, Grieving, and the Fight for Faith. He holds a BA from Wheaton College, an MDiv from Covenant Theological Seminary, and both a ThM and PhD from Midwestern Baptist Theological Seminary. He is a Marine Corps veteran. He is also the lead pastor of the First Baptist Church St. John located in St. Louis, Missouri. He is married to Laura and has five lovely children.

    View all posts
Picture of Josh Holler

Josh Holler

Josh Holler is an award winning author of Redeeming Warriors: Veteran Suicide, Grieving, and the Fight for Faith. He holds a BA from Wheaton College, an MDiv from Covenant Theological Seminary, and both a ThM and PhD from Midwestern Baptist Theological Seminary. He is a Marine Corps veteran. He is also the lead pastor of the First Baptist Church St. John located in St. Louis, Missouri. He is married to Laura and has five lovely children.